Religious freedom, even when we disagree
Dear friends, neighbors, and brothers and sisters in Christ, like many of you, I have been following with interest the news surrounding the planned Islamic Center Ezan in Urbandale. The Bosnian Muslims building this center are not the Muslim extremists we have heard about on the news and social media. They have been members of our community for decades. They have learned our language, lived next door, worked in the next cubicle, started businesses up the street, attended our schools, and more. They are familiar faces at the bank and the grocery store checkout, and even though they may not share the same faith, they are our neighbors and friends.
This morning, I read a social media post from the mayor of Urbandale reminding us that Iowa has a long and treasured history of welcoming people fleeing persecution of various sorts. He pointed out that Iowa has been welcoming people from far away lands since Robert Ray welcomed the Tai Dam in the 1970s, and in fact, many of these have settled in my immediate neighborhood. The Tai Dam established Tai Village just a few blocks from my old home. My church includes people from multiple African nations who fled from violence and persecution to the United States and Des Moines, and I count as friends and neighbors people from Burma, Afghanistan, Syria, and more, many of whom do not share my faith.
Iowa’s heritage of embracing strangers, however, goes back much farther than Robert Ray. Among the state’s earliest European settlers were people from Germany, Ireland, Holland, Norway, Sweden, and more. Many of these came to escape the prejudice they encountered elsewhere, and they gathered in communities where they could speak in their own language and worship in their own way.
Going back even farther, it is ironic that the recent uproar comes in November as we prepare to celebrate Thanksgiving. In fact, the holiday we will celebrate next week was inspired by men and women who came to America seeking the freedom to practice their own religion their own way, and their experiences became foundational to freedoms we take for granted every day, including the freedom of religion.
Those of us who claim to be followers of Christ, especially, must remember Jesus did not spout venom against those who believed and lived differently. He drove a legion of evil spirits from a man in the region of the Gerasenes in Mark 5, healed the daughter of a Canaanite woman in Matthew 15, and told an illustration in which a Samaritan was the hero in Luke 10. It is easy for us, two thousand years removed from these situations, to miss that these descriptors were clear indicators that these people did not believe as Jesus and his disciples did.
Some might point to the Old Testament, where Israel was commanded to drive out the pagans so they would not be drawn into idolatry, but this is an incredibly selective view of Scriptures. When Israel left Egypt during the exodus, “a mixed crowd also went up with them” (Exodus 12:38). Their earliest laws both considered and protected resident aliens based on Israel’s own experience as resident aliens (e.g., Exodus 20:10; 22:21; 23:9), and even as they were claiming the Promised Land, it is acknowledged that there were “resident aliens who lived among them” (Joshua 8:33, 35; 20:9).
Moreover, when Jerusalem fell and the Jewish exile began at the end of 2 Kings and 2 Chronicles, God’s people were suddenly a religious minority scattered among the nations and living alongside people from a wide variety of faiths and cultures. Yet, God commanded them to “build houses and live in them. Plant gardens and eat their produce. Find wives for yourselves, and have sons and daughters. Find wives for your sons and give your daughters to men in marriage so that they may bear sons and daughters. Multiply there; do not decrease. Pursue the well-being of the city I have deported you to. Pray to the Lord on its behalf, for when it thrives, you will thrive” (Jeremiah 29:4-7 CSB).
Notice, God did not tell them to isolate themselves from the surrounding community, demand their neighbors adopt the Jewish religion, or protest the presence of other faiths. Rather, he instructed them to invest themselves in the well-being of the community where they were religious outsiders. That is, they were to live and work alongside these neighbors whose convictions were fundamentally different from their own.
So also, the gospel did not spread in Acts by denouncing people who did not believe in Jesus. The disciples in Acts 4 prayed that they would be able to boldly proclaim the gospel rather than silence their opponents. In Acts 8, there was great joy in the Samaritan city because Philip came proclaiming the Messiah (i.e., Savior) and healing people. In Acts 10, Peter’s message to Cornelius was an invitation rather than derision. In Acts 17, Paul actually used the altar of an unknown God as a springboard into an absolutely masterful gospel presentation. Instead of ranting and railing, Paul challenged the Corinthians to adapt their methods to connect with unbelievers (1 Corinthians 9:19-23) and “plead on Christ’s behalf, ‘Be reconciled to God’” (2 Corinthians 5:20 CSB, emphasis added).
Furthermore, Scriptures and the historical persecution of God’s people prompted the founders of our nation, several of whom were Christians, to establish religious freedom for all as the first guarantee of the Bill of Rights. That is, Congress was proscribed from making laws to either establish a religion or prohibit citizens’ free exercise of their own religion even before the freedoms of speech, assembly, petition, and bearing arms were established, and the Fourteenth Amendment applied this same proscription to state and local governments.
This is not to be confused with endorsing every religion. You may, as I do, unequivocally affirm that Jesus is the way, the truth, and the life (John 14:6), and that salvation is found in him alone (Acts 4:12), but genuine faith cannot be coerced. It must not be coerced. Indeed, the gospel of Jesus is substantially emptied when we demand a government that withholds freedom from those who have not received him. Therefore, the freedom to worship according to one’s convictions must be protected even for those with whom we do not agree. Otherwise, it would not really be religious freedom at all.
Religious freedom, then, was not an afterthought, and mosques built in our communities are not unanticipated or unfortunate side effects. They are exactly what our Christian and civil forebears meant to allow. Generations of American veterans fought and died to ensure this freedom, and we must be willing to protect it today, even–no, especially–when those exercising it believe differently than we do.
