[Vibrant Church]: Beacon of holiness
The city of Thyatira was founded in approximately 300 BC as an inland military outpost. While the city never gained the political or commercial prominence of other cities, it did become a center for the textile and manufacturing industries. Instead of people flocking to the city to buy things, though, Thyatiran merchants (e.g., Lydia in Acts 16:14) fanned out across the world to sell their wares. This broad distribution network meant that, even though people were not flocking to Thyatira, the city was nevertheless well known throughout the Ancient Near East.
It was also well known that Thyatira was home to more trade guilds than any other city in the ancient world. Each of these guilds came with its own patron god, and guild functions routinely involved worship of this god, including feasts, sacrifices, and even prostitution. Refusing to participate in these guild rituals was tantamount to rejecting guild membership, and people who did not belong to a guild were not allowed to work in Thyatira.
For Christians, this led to a situation not unlike that in Pergamum. There, Christians were tempted to mix the truths of Christianity with other ideas to make their faith more palatable. In Thyatira, saints were tempted to mix the behaviors of Christianity with the sinful practices of their pagan neighbors, and apparently, at least some of them succumbed. That is, there was sin in the church, and in Revelation 2:18-29, the resurrected Jesus aimed to address it.
“Write to the angel of the church in Thyatira: Thus says the Son of God, the one whose eyes are like a fiery flame and whose feet are like fine bronze: I know your works—your love, faithfulness, service, and endurance. I know that your last works are greater than the first. But I have this against you: You tolerate the woman Jezebel, who calls herself a prophetess and teaches and deceives my servants to commit sexual immorality and to eat meat sacrificed to idols. I gave her time to repent, but she does not want to repent of her sexual immorality. Look, I will throw her into a sickbed and those who commit adultery with her into great affliction. Unless they repent of her works, I will strike her children dead. Then all the churches will know that I am the one who examines minds and hearts, and I will give to each of you according to your works. I say to the rest of you in Thyatira, who do not hold this teaching, who haven’t known “the so-called secrets of Satan” —as they say—I am not putting any other burden on you. Only hold on to what you have until I come. The one who conquers and who keeps my works to the end: I will give him authority over the nations— and he will rule them with an iron scepter; he will shatter them like pottery — just as I have received this from my Father. I will also give him the morning star.
“Let anyone who has ears to hear listen to what the Spirit says to the churches.
The Good: There is a remnant
As he did with each of the previous three churches, Jesus began his letter to the church at Thyatira with a note of praise. Specifically, he commended them for their “love, faithfulness, service, and endurance” (19). These, of course, were supposed to be hallmarks of the Christian faith and practice. Love and faithfulness were identified by St. Paul as natural products of the Spirit working within us (Galatians 5:22), and service and endurance were extolled in multiple places throughout Scripture. Thus, at least some of the saints in Thyatira were believing and doing everything right.
More than that, Jesus celebrated that “your last works are greater than the first” (19). That is, they were doing more and better things now than they were when the church was first founded. They were growing in their faith and practice.
The Bad: They tolerated sin
After this brief note of praise, however, Jesus dropped a big “but” at the beginning of verse 20. As well as some of the saints at Thyatira were doing, there was a problem. As he said to the churches at both Ephesus and Pergamum, he had something against the church there: “You tolerate the woman Jezebel.”
Scholars debate whether Jezebel was the actual name of a singular person causing problems in Thyatira or merely a symbolic reference. If it was the person’s actual name, it was a striking coincidence because Jezebel was the name of the wife of King Ahab in 1 and 2 Kings. In case that does not ring a bell, Ahab was a shockingly evil king. In 1 Kings 16:30, he “did what was evil in the Lord’s sight more than all who were before him (emphasis added).” As bad as he was on his own, however, Ahab’s sin was compounded after he married Jezebel. Because of her, he built an altar to Baal inside a temple he built for Baal in the city of Samaria (1 Kings 16:32), erected at least one Asherah pole (1 Kings 16:33), and then proceeded to worship and serve these pagan idols. The people of God were supposed to worship and serve the Lord exclusively, and that in the temple in Jerusalem. Additionally, at Jezebel’s prompting, Ahab ordered the slaughter of the Lord’s prophets (1 Kings 18:4), replaced them with 450 prophets of Baal and 400 prophets of Asherah (1 Kings 18:19), and summoned the entire northern kingdom to gather at Mount Carmel to worship these idols with him.
Whether or not Jezebel was her real name, there was at least one woman in Thyatira who made idolatry, adultery, and sin look and sound good. Some of the ways she did that are hinted at in Jesus’ letter. In verse 19, Jesus introduced himself as “the Son of God.” Perhaps Jezebel aimed to convince them Jesus was just a good teacher or moral leader. So also, in verse 23, Jesus made a point to say he is “the One who examines minds and hearts.” Maybe she aimed to convince the saints of Thyatira Jesus was not the One and there was someone else (perhaps several someone elses) who judged. Possibly, she tried to convince them Jesus was merely a way, a truth, and a life, and when that did not work, she did not hesitate to use force.
Whatever her precise teaching, Jezebel encouraged the saints at Thyatira to compromise their allegiance to Jesus through sin. In doing so, she undermined Jesus’ authority and tarnished his testimony.
The problem at Thyatira, then, was significant. They were allowing sin to go unchecked, and when those who promoted sin retained positions of leadership, the church was sending the clear message that what God said was bad was actually okay. In short, they were calling evil good and good evil, and what does the Bible say about that? Isaiah 5:20 pronounces, “Woe to those who call evil good and good evil, who substitute darkness for light and light for darkness.”
Before you think there is no way you or your church would ever do this, it should be recognized that the church at Thyatira probably never intended for this to happen, either. Indeed, Jesus provided a key clue as to how they arrived at this point in the verb he used in verse 20: You tolerate the woman Jezebel. In the original Greek, the term means “to allow” or simply “not to restrain.” The idea, then, is not that they set out to foster sin in the camp but that they just failed to stop it when it appeared. So Jezebel took one step, and no one stopped her. She took another, and no one stopped her. In short, her corrupting influence grew one step at a time because no one stopped her, and the longer no one stopped her, the more influential she became until, finally, she was able to call herself a prophetess and teach and deceive people who were earnestly trying to serve God into participating in sin with her.
The Ugly: Sin wrecks Jesus’ reputation
It is at this point tempting to acknowledge the situation but dismiss it as harmless. After all, Jezebel and her followers were consenting grown ups, and they were not hurting anyone. Or were they?
In verse 22, Jesus warned that, because of her sin, he would “throw her into a sickbed.” This may not have been literal, physical illness; ancient people recognized sin as a sort of soul sickness. Whether physically or spiritually, or a combination of the two, she would eventually waste away. A key word here, however, is eventually. Recently, a member of our community was taken to the hospital with severe abdominal pain. After examining him and running numerous tests, doctors discovered cancer throughout his body. Were there signs and symptoms before he went to the hospital? Of course, but they were either overlooked or dismissed as no big deal. Like a person with an undiagnosed, untreated disease, sinners may seem to thrive for a long time. In fact, they may never become physically sick, and they may reach a point where their consciences are so seared they never feel a pang of guilt. Yet, sooner or later, sin is at work destroying something
Similarly, Jezebel’s sin was hurting the people who followed her. Still in verse 22, Jesus warned that he would throw “those who commit adultery with her into great affliction,” and in verse 23, he added, “I will strike her children dead.” Again, this may not mean physical affliction or death, but the effects of spiritual death are no less real. She was, then, leading those who fell in line behind her to their ruin, too.
Even more, notice what Jesus said would be the result of Jezebel’s judgment. Back in verse 23, he pronounced, “Then all the churches will know that I am the one who examines minds and hearts, and I will give to each of you according to your works.” Jesus here used a positive statement, telling us what he was going to do and what would happen as a result, but what if this were reframed as a negative statement, telling us what would happen if Jesus did not strike her children? In this scenario, the churches would not know that he is the one who examines minds and hearts and gives to each according to their works. Their tolerance of sin would send a confusing message about the character of Jesus and lead people to question God’s omniscience, justice, and holiness. His reputation would be ruined and his glory tarnished because people saw that he tolerated sin among the self-proclaimed leaders of his people. The church’s tolerance of sin thus misrepresented the very Savior they claimed to follow, and Jesus was not about to let that happen!
The Solution: Hold on to holiness.
But what were the Thyatirans to do about the sin that had infiltrated their church? What are we to do when sin infiltrates our churches? Fortunately, in verses 24-25, Jesus provided a plan which was simple to understand even if it was not easy to implement. Speaking to those who had not followed Jezebel, he exhorted, “Only hold on to what you have until I come.” The Greek term rendered “hold on” was used by the military to speak of seizing a territory and doing whatever was necessary to keep it. It included the ideas of digging in and tenaciously defending that piece of land. Thus, Jesus’ instruction was to stop tolerating sin but to dig in and hold on to the love, faithfulness, service, endurance, and good works for which they were commended in verse 19. That is, they were to hold on to holiness with everything they had.
In Matthew 18:15-20, Jesus outlined the proper response to sin in the church. The first step of this process involved a direct but discreet confrontation of the person in sin: “go tell him his fault, between you and him alone” (15). If the person declined to repent, then the second step was to escalate the matter by confronting the person again with “one or two others” (16). These others would serve as witnesses in two ways. First, they would affirm to the sinner that their behavior was wrong. Second, they would be able to verify that the person repented and hold them accountable to that commitment. Alternatively, they could testify to their lack of response in the next step, which was to “tell the church” (17). Finally, the confrontation was made public, and if the person still refused to repent, they were to be considered “like a Gentile and a tax collector to you.” This may not have involved excommunication: Jesus welcomed tax collectors and sinners. At the very least, this meant removing them from leadership, and if they persisted in sin, then the church was to recognize they were no longer part of the body of Christ.
So that we are not confused about what that looks like, though, it is important to recognize that Jesus was unwavering in his commitment to holiness, but his response to outsiders was often exactly the opposite of ours. We tend to bash the sin of the unbeliever who does not know any better and may be desperate for God even as we rationalize and excuse the sin of the self-proclaimed saint among us. Jesus, however, was gentle with the sinners he met. For example, he refused to lambast the Samaritan woman at the well (John 4), sought out the tax collectors, welcomed and hung out with children and sinners, and embraced the tears and fragrant offering of the sinful woman. Yet, he minced no words with those who were self-righteous and assumed the mantle of leadership while fostering sin. He called Pharisees and their ilk a brood of vipers and whitewashed tombs. Thus, if the person stopped claiming to be a Christ-follower and leader in the church, then they could be treated with gentleness like most other sinners, but if they persisted in these claims, then the church was to make clear they were not a part of the covenant community.
This all makes sense when we realize that the goal of confronting sin is never to punish or exclude. Rather, our ultimate objective must be to restore the sinner. This goal must govern every bit of the process.
Throughout this letter, Jesus dropped hints as to why it was so important that the Thyatirans hold on to holiness in this way. If they failed to do so, he reminded them in verse 18 that he was “the one whose eyes are like a fiery flame” and had “feet… like fine bronze,” and in verse 27, he warned that “he will shatter… like pottery” those who refuse to be purified. Verse 18 was a reference to John’s description of the resurrected Jesus from Revelation 1, but for the Thyatirans, it was more than that. They were supremely familiar with the fiery flames of the furnaces their factories used to heat metal and remove impurities so it could be strengthened. They knew that fine bronze was pure, and bronze that was not pure would, under stress, shatter like pottery. Put these together, and we discover that holding onto holiness is critical because, sooner or later, one way or another, Jesus was going to remove the impurities.
Conversely, if they did hold on to holiness, Jesus promised in verse 26 to “give him authority over the nations” and in verse 28 to “give him the morning star.” This first promise is simple enough: those who effectively defended holiness would be victorious over sin in this life and given a place of honor and authority next to Jesus in the next. The second promise, many scholars believe, was a reference to the Messiah: Jesus will give himself, his presence and power, to the person who clings to holiness.
In the end, the church at Thyatira faced a crucial decision. They could continue tolerating sin, compromising their allegiance to Christ, and undermining his reputation, or they could renew their commitment to holiness and so become the truly vibrant church Jesus designed them to be.
Our churches face the same crucial decision today. The truly vibrant church does not merely grow, serve, love, and do good works. It is becoming increasingly like Christ. Its holiness is not the harsh, condescending self-righteousness of the Pharisees, which repulses and condemns people. Rather, it is a beckoning holiness that demonstrates that Jesus’ way is better, invites others to join in, and ushers them into victory and the very presence and power of Jesus. The truly vibrant church will never be content to tolerate what Jesus came to overcome!
